The Vatican Nativity scene, designed by Palestinian artists Johny Andonia and Faten Nastas Mitwasi, has been removed from the Paul VI audience hall following a global controversy. The scene, titled “Nativity of Bethlehem 2024,” featured the infant Jesus resting on a traditional Palestinian keffiyeh, which many interpreted as a pro-Palestinian statement. The design choice sparked backlash from the Israeli and Jewish communities, with some questioning the pope’s intentions and accusing him of rebranding Jesus as Palestinian .
Pope Francis had unveiled the Nativity scene during a December 7 audience, calling for an end to war and conflict, particularly in Gaza, where he has repeatedly condemned the violence as “immoral” ³. The scene was crafted from olive trees in the Holy Land and featured a Star of Bethlehem made from mother of pearl, with an inscription in both Latin and Arabic.
The controversy surrounding the Nativity scene highlights the complexities of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and the role of the Catholic Church in promoting peace and justice. The Vatican’s decision to remove the scene has sparked debate, with some arguing that it was a necessary step to avoid further polarization